Opinion 2017-05-19T20:27:29+00:00

The following articles, except where noted, were originally published in the Keene Sentinel.

Wedding-cake Ruling Falls Flat on Key Issues

June is brides’ month. It’s also Supreme Court month, the time when the Court issues its blockbuster decisions for the term and then recesses until October. On June 4, the Court decided Masterpiece Cakeshop v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission. That is the case where Jack the baker refused to [...]

When Being Called a Liar Becomes a Federal Case

I don’t know whether our first president actually said “I cannot tell a lie,” but I do know that defamation law is experiencing a resurgence of “liar” cases, including one against our current president. That case is being brought by a woman named Sumner Zervos, who appeared on “The [...]

Non-Disclosure Agreements and the Art of the Deal

Ten days before the 2016 presidential election, “Peggy Peterson (PP)” entered into a non-disclosure agreement with “EC, LLC and/or David Dennison (DD).” The deal was simple. She got $130,000, and he got her silence in the form of a promise not to disclose any “Confidential Information” about “Dennison,” including [...]

Union Dues and the Constitutional Right Not to Speak

The United States is a land of free speech. Nowhere is speech freer. Winston Churchill I’ve never doubted that freedom of speech and of the press are the cornerstones of American democracy. The right of free speech is not absolute, but if the government wants to limit or restrict [...]

Who Makes the Call; lawyer or client?

The Sixth Amendment says that in all criminal prosecutions, the accused “shall enjoy the right … to have the Assistance of Counsel for his defence.” Like so much of the Bill of Rights, the Founding Fathers didn’t tell us exactly what they had in mind, leaving it up to [...]

Is Impeachment Political or Legal

Since former FBI Director James Comey testified before the Senate Intelligence Committee last June, there has been a more or less steady impeachment drumroll. According to recent polls, more than 40% of voters think President Trump should be impeached, while less than 40% think he is doing a good [...]

First Amendment Shouldn’t be Used as an Excuse

In the usual free speech case, someone claims that his or her right of free expression is being infringed. There is another side to this constitutional coin, a “negative” right, meaning the right not to be compelled to speak. This right was the basis for a 1943 decision where [...]

Wedding-cake Bakers and the Constitution

David Mullins and Charlie Craig live in Colorado. In 2012, same-sex marriage wasn’t allowed in that state, and the Supreme Court’s decision was three years away. So, they decided to travel to Massachusetts, where gay marriage had been legally recognized since 2004, and then have a wedding party back [...]

Gerrymandering and the Sanctity of the Vote

Gill v. Whitford, the gerrymandering case heard last week by the Supreme Court, involves two lines. One is an actual line, meaning the contours of voting districts within a state. The other is the abstract line known as “justiciability,” meaning whether this voting question should be decided by the [...]

Plausibility, the Press, and Sarah Palin

When it comes to filing lawsuits, it used to be that lawyers could write a complaint saying little more than “he done me wrong” and worry about the details later. “Sure,” the lawyer could tell the client. “We’ll throw something at the wall and see what sticks.” No more. [...]